10 unions back Labour MP’s bid to uphold settlement rights for skilled workers
Neil Duncan-Jordan MP’s plan to prevent the doubling of the qualifying period for migrant workers to secure the right to stay in the UK will be debated in Parliament today (Tuesday 17th November). Cross-party MPs’ and ten trade unions, including UNISON and Unite, have backed the amendment.
Following a campaign led by UNISON, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood announced an exemption for care workers and other occupations so that they would retain a five-year route to settled status. The decision has however left many other skilled workers facing uncertainty about their future status.
Duncan-Jordan’s amendment would prevent the Home Secretary, from retrospectively changing the qualifying period for indefinite leave to remain for skilled worker visa holders already in the UK. It would prevent the qualifying period from being extended and stop language, income, residence or other settlement requirements from being made more onerous for existing visa holders.
Neil Duncan-Jordan MP said:
“It is totally unfair to go back on our word to skilled workers who built their lives around promises our Government made to them. I welcome the concession for care workers and other, but what is unfair to one group is also unfair to another.
People who are just days away from applying for settlement will now face at least five more years of waiting and uncertainty. I have a constituent, a biomedical scientist, who is now scared for their future. Who in their right mind wants to show people with those skills the door? It also sends the wrong message about the sort of country we are if someone can come here on a promise, build their life around it, and then be told our Government’s word didn’t mean a thing.
I understand that the public want an immigration system that works. The British public also believe in fair play: that you should get out what you put in, and that friends and neighbours who have become part of the fabric of their communities should not have their lives turned upside down after years of contributing.
This Starmer-era plan runs against our Labour values. That is why ten trade unions have backed my amendment. Workers keeping our railways running, officers working in Trading Standards and non-medical staff within our NHS are exactly the kind of people this country needs.
For our party to argue that those who earn the most should get preferential treatment and see their route to settled status reduced, you have to ask what’s going on? Since when did someone’s contribution and value to our society rest on how much they earn? Retrospection is simply wrong.”
UNISON general secretary Andrea Egan said:
“Migrant workers came to this country on a clear promise: work for five years in our public services, follow the rules and you can settle here. They have kept their side of the bargain, now the government must do the same.
“UNISON members forced the home secretary to back down on her original plans. But the exemptions are partial and arbitrary. A care worker sponsored a week after the cut-off date faces ten years to settlement rather than five. Nursing auxiliaries sponsored since July 2025 have no route to settlement at all.
“It’s time to stop demonising migrant workers and start celebrating their contribution. Neil Duncan-Jordan’s amendment would help hold the government to the rules that were in place when these workers were granted their visas. That is a matter of basic fairness and justice. Every MP should vote for it.”
UNITE General Secretary Sharon Graham said:
“The retrospective element to indefinite leave to remain is cruel and totally unjust.
It is simply not fair to bring workers to Britain and change the goalposts mid-stream. Whilst Unite has welcomed the government listening and acting on care workers, NHS workers and teaching assistants, it is now time to extend this to include other workers.
Unite has also made the point that is unacceptable that an NHS doctor who fought Covid would wait five years, while a city ‘finance bro’ paying additional tax is able to go through the system in three.”
RMT General Secretary Eddie Dempsey said:
“This amendment is about workplace justice and highlights that it is wholly unfair for a Labour government to penalise workers who are making an invaluable contribution to our economy and communities.”
“The Government should protect workers who are already in the UK and support the amendment.”
UCU General Secretary Jo Grady said:
“Any changes to the rules on indefinite leave to remain must not be imposed retrospectively on people who have already come to the UK, built their lives here and made decisions about their futures based on the rules in place when they arrived.
“Our members working in post-16 education have come to the UK, made enormous contributions, and put down roots in their communities. It is fundamentally unfair to change the goalposts on them after they have made that commitment.
“New Clause 62 would provide an important safeguard for existing visa holders, protecting them from retrospective increases to the qualifying period and other more onerous settlement requirements. Our members deserve certainty, fairness and the ability to plan their futures. We urge MPs to support this amendment.”
PCS General Secretary Fran Heathcote said:
“PCS members working in the civil service have recently lost their jobs and been forced out of the country because of retrospective increases in the skilled worker visa threshold. These are dedicated public servants who have been trained, are experienced and do vital government work.
“Let’s be clear this is the Government deporting its own workforce, because the Government does not pay them enough. Years of below inflation pay settlements mean civil servants are earning less in real terms than in 2010.”
NEU General Secretary Daniel Kebede said:
“Migrant workers built Britain. They built our NHS, they care for our parents, keep our transport running and look after our children. We need to stand with them, not threaten their right to stay. We should be blaming the billionaires, not migrants.”
CWU General Secretary Dave Ward said:
"It's wrong that thousands of working people are being faced with an uncertain future after playing by the rules.
"These migrant workers have made a serious contribution to our country and our society, and the current government proposals are simply not fair.
"We urge the government to do right by these workers by sticking to the original rules from when they were granted visas in the first place."
NASUWT General Secretary, Matt Wrack said:
“A retrospective change to leave to remain is fundamentally unfair. We know many of our members
across the country will be impacted by the government’s proposed legislation. These are teachers who dedicate their lives to educate young people, and these changes will submit them to huge uncertainty.
The impact of these changes will make working and learning conditions worse in our school and colleges.
I am pleased to see Neil Duncan-Jordan’s amendment which would ensure this government honours its pre-existing commitment to workers across the country.
All workers should be able to expect a Labour government to treat them fairly. Please support this amendment.”
BFAWU General Secretary Sarah Woolley said:
The Bakers, Food and Allied Workers’ Union (BFAWU) fully supports New Clause 62 and calls on MPs to back this important amendment.
We are seeing an increasing number of members facing uncertainty and anxiety over their immigration status, including workers who have built their lives in the UK, contributed to our economy and communities, and now face the prospect of being unable to remain because of changing salary thresholds and immigration requirements.
It is fundamentally unfair to move the goalposts for people who came to this country legally, followed the rules and made long-term decisions based on the settlement arrangements in place when they arrived.
Workers should not face the threat of losing their livelihoods, homes and futures because the Government decides to retrospectively change the rules.
We believe that every worker deserves security, dignity and fair treatment, regardless of where they were born.
New Clause 62 is an important step towards protecting existing visa holders from retrospective changes to their pathway to settlement, and we urge MPs across Parliament to support it.
TSSA General Secretary Maryam Eslamdoust said:
“Migrant workers are damned if they work and damned if they don’t. A route to indefinite leave to remain that values a banker above a carer or transport worker is inherently unfair. The Government must set the same qualifying period for all, without discrimination by occupation or income.”